By The Common Man
This week, The Common Man is counting down the 40 worst offseasons in baseball history. Part 1 is here. Part 2 is here. And Part 4 is here. Today, he continues, counting down from 20-11. Today, the Braves trade a whole pitching staff, the Orioles and D-backs get burned by bad backs, the Twins get nothing for the best pitcher in baseball, the Expos and A's sell everything that isn't nailed down, and Christy Mathewson. Remember, from yesterday, TCM is trying to "account for the Wins Above Replacement lost by each team over the next five years as a result of their actions, or (for modern teams) until a player traded away, waived, or released became a free agent again. He has also tried to account for teams whose terrible moves cost them postseason berths, and also for how fans likely felt if they were watching their team get gutted or flail about." And now, back to the rankings!
Wednesday, February 16, 2011
The 40 Worst Off-Seasons Ever, Part 3
Labels:
40 Greatest,
baseball,
baseball history,
off-seasons
SweetSpot Roundup 2/16
Capitol Avenue Club (Braves): Consider an earthquake
Just how sabermetrically inclined is the Braves' new manager?
Disciples of Uecker (Brewers): 2011 Maple Street Press Brewers Annual
Jack's hawking his wares, but I have a feeling this is going to be a publication you're going to want if you're interested in the Brew Crew or the NL Central.
The View From the Bleachers (Cubs): Cubs trade Tony Thomas to Boston for Robert Coello
A minor deal, but one that could pay off in the Chicago bullpen.
Dodger Thoughts: 2011 Spring Training Primer
Jon Weisman has a crackerjack preview of the Dodgers' upcoming Spring Training. A must read.
Mets Today: Once Again, Would the Mets Sign Pujols?
"Assuming nothing changes in ownership between now and then, it’s a foregone conclusion that the Mets will be in no position to get in on the bidding should Pujols be a free agent."
Bay City Ball (Giants): Tracking the 'Best Shapes'
So far, only two players on the Giants are in the best shapes of their career. I blame the school systems for not teaching enough Geometry.
Nationals Baseball: A Number 1 Problem
A post about Livan Hernandez without an Elton John joke is a rare gift indeed.
Ducksnorts (Padres): Great Pitching Duels in Padres History, Kevin Brown vs. Daryl Kile
I really like this series that Geoff has put together. And it's nice to take a moment to remember Kile, a terrific pitcher who was taken too young.
Crashburn Alley (Phillies): Are the Phillies Missing Right-Handed Power?
Well, do they? Bill doesn't keep us in suspense for too long.
Redleg Nation: What to Expect From Mike Leake
Last year Mike Leake was a hotshot rookie who fatigued down the stretch for the Reds. Now he wants to be let off the leash. Should he be turned loose?
Ghostrunner on First (Blue Jays): Doom, Gloom and Soaking up the Fun
"Just about everything looks good for the future of the Blue Jays. The present...not so much. It isn't that the upcoming season is already lost or that I don't eagerly await Opening Day. I just think there are many short-term potholes between the Jays and a steady cycle of success."
Pro Ball NW (Mariners): The Last Stand (Until the Next One)
Jon looks at some players on the roster who might be in danger of hitting the waiver wire before Opening Day.
Baseball Time in Arlington (Rangers): Projecting The Rangers' Opening Day Roster...On February 14th
"Barring some more chaos on the Young front, this really is a remarkably locked-in roster already -- for perhaps the first time in recent memory, all of the Rangers' position players seem to be set.... Probably the only remotely controversial thing about this roster, in fact, is my placement of a non-roster Dave Bush in the No. 5 spot and Derek Holland in the long-relief spot, which I admittedly can't provide much justification for beyond saying that it's what I'm feeling in my gut."
The Ray Area: 61!
No, not 61*; that's the number of players the Rays are bringing in to spring training. Mark looks at some past classes of invitees.
Fire Brand of the AL (Red Sox): Ten Things to Watch For This Spring
Number ten is the one I'll be keeping an eye on; Tony Pena, Jr., former shortstop who hits like a pitcher, in his attempt to make the Sox' roster as a pitcher who pitches like one.
Royals Authority: David DeJesus: Not Easily Replaced
"I keep forgetting that David Dejesus isn’t a Royal anymore. It’s partly because the departure of Zack Greinke was much more publicized. It’s also probably because David Dejesus was the kind of player who was always under-rated and under-appreciated."
Nick's Twins Blog: Windows
Preach it, Nick: "By trading Liriano right now for a package of prospects, which Christensen presents as a possibility in drawing comparisons to the Zack Greinke and Matt Garza trades, the Twins would effectively be slamming the window shut on themselves. Hypothetically, they could still compete for a division title, but contending teams just don't trade their best pitcher away."
It's About the Money, Stupid (Yankees): More on CC's opt-out and the likeliness of it being exercised
Jason figures CC likely will opt out of his current contract after this season. But his analysis is a must-read.
Just how sabermetrically inclined is the Braves' new manager?
Disciples of Uecker (Brewers): 2011 Maple Street Press Brewers Annual
Jack's hawking his wares, but I have a feeling this is going to be a publication you're going to want if you're interested in the Brew Crew or the NL Central.
The View From the Bleachers (Cubs): Cubs trade Tony Thomas to Boston for Robert Coello
A minor deal, but one that could pay off in the Chicago bullpen.
Dodger Thoughts: 2011 Spring Training Primer
Jon Weisman has a crackerjack preview of the Dodgers' upcoming Spring Training. A must read.
Mets Today: Once Again, Would the Mets Sign Pujols?
"Assuming nothing changes in ownership between now and then, it’s a foregone conclusion that the Mets will be in no position to get in on the bidding should Pujols be a free agent."
Bay City Ball (Giants): Tracking the 'Best Shapes'
So far, only two players on the Giants are in the best shapes of their career. I blame the school systems for not teaching enough Geometry.
Nationals Baseball: A Number 1 Problem
A post about Livan Hernandez without an Elton John joke is a rare gift indeed.
Ducksnorts (Padres): Great Pitching Duels in Padres History, Kevin Brown vs. Daryl Kile
I really like this series that Geoff has put together. And it's nice to take a moment to remember Kile, a terrific pitcher who was taken too young.
Crashburn Alley (Phillies): Are the Phillies Missing Right-Handed Power?
Well, do they? Bill doesn't keep us in suspense for too long.
Redleg Nation: What to Expect From Mike Leake
Last year Mike Leake was a hotshot rookie who fatigued down the stretch for the Reds. Now he wants to be let off the leash. Should he be turned loose?
Ghostrunner on First (Blue Jays): Doom, Gloom and Soaking up the Fun
"Just about everything looks good for the future of the Blue Jays. The present...not so much. It isn't that the upcoming season is already lost or that I don't eagerly await Opening Day. I just think there are many short-term potholes between the Jays and a steady cycle of success."
Pro Ball NW (Mariners): The Last Stand (Until the Next One)
Jon looks at some players on the roster who might be in danger of hitting the waiver wire before Opening Day.
Baseball Time in Arlington (Rangers): Projecting The Rangers' Opening Day Roster...On February 14th
"Barring some more chaos on the Young front, this really is a remarkably locked-in roster already -- for perhaps the first time in recent memory, all of the Rangers' position players seem to be set.... Probably the only remotely controversial thing about this roster, in fact, is my placement of a non-roster Dave Bush in the No. 5 spot and Derek Holland in the long-relief spot, which I admittedly can't provide much justification for beyond saying that it's what I'm feeling in my gut."
The Ray Area: 61!
No, not 61*; that's the number of players the Rays are bringing in to spring training. Mark looks at some past classes of invitees.
Fire Brand of the AL (Red Sox): Ten Things to Watch For This Spring
Number ten is the one I'll be keeping an eye on; Tony Pena, Jr., former shortstop who hits like a pitcher, in his attempt to make the Sox' roster as a pitcher who pitches like one.
Royals Authority: David DeJesus: Not Easily Replaced
"I keep forgetting that David Dejesus isn’t a Royal anymore. It’s partly because the departure of Zack Greinke was much more publicized. It’s also probably because David Dejesus was the kind of player who was always under-rated and under-appreciated."
Nick's Twins Blog: Windows
Preach it, Nick: "By trading Liriano right now for a package of prospects, which Christensen presents as a possibility in drawing comparisons to the Zack Greinke and Matt Garza trades, the Twins would effectively be slamming the window shut on themselves. Hypothetically, they could still compete for a division title, but contending teams just don't trade their best pitcher away."
It's About the Money, Stupid (Yankees): More on CC's opt-out and the likeliness of it being exercised
Jason figures CC likely will opt out of his current contract after this season. But his analysis is a must-read.
Labels:
baseball,
SweetSpot Roundup
Tuesday, February 15, 2011
3 Questions: Baltimore Orioles
By Bill
The Orioles are our second-to-last AL team to be questioned. They've made a bunch of fairly big moves this offseason, which you think would make them one of the more fun ones to talk about. You'd be wrong, though. Like, really wrong.
1. Is a good last-place team better than a bad last-place team?
Maybe that's not fair. PECOTA, after all, likes them to finish fourth, six games ahead of the Blue Jays. I just can't see it; the Jays have probably gotten a bit worse and the Orioles have gotten a bit better, but not to the tune of a 25-game swing from 2010.
The point, though, is that even that very rosy projection has the Orioles at 82-80 -- ten games out of first, nine out of a playoff spot, and stuck behind probably the three best teams in the league. So what are they doing acquiring three players -- Derrek Lee, Vladimir Guerrero and J.J. Hardy -- who will be free agents after this season? With those three guys, they've spent $21 million for, basically, a chance to move from a distant fifth place to a distant fourth.
And this is fun: a few days ago, GM Andy MacPhail was speaking to some law students when he said that Alex Rodriguez's huge 2001 contract with the Rangers was "the worst signing in the history of baseball in my view." And why? Because "the needle didn't move at all. The team didn't improve. Attendance didn't go up." MacPhail hasn't spent anywhere near A-Rod money this offseason, but it's hard to imagine these moves turning out any differently.
2. How Good Is Matt Wieters?
And speaking of PECOTA: in 2009, before he'd played a game in the big leagues, the system saw Wieters as putting up one of the greatest seasons a catcher has ever had: .311/.395/.544, with 31 home runs. Of course, that didn't happen, though he was about an average hitter in 2009, which in itself is impressive enough for a 23 year old catcher. But then he took a step back in 2010.
Wieters is still the same guy who was taken fifth overall in the draft, was the #1 prospect entering 2009, and hit an incredible .343/.438/.576 in his minor league career. We're still a couple years from being able to say he won't be a star in the major leagues. I get the sense people are writing him off already, but if you're going to bet on somebody to come up with a huge year out of nowhere this year (and its coming "out of nowhere" pretty much means you shouldn't bet on it, or whatever), Wieters would seem to be a pretty good choice.
3. Can Mark Reynolds Hit (in the AL East)?
I've written about Reynolds several times already (here and here and here), because he's fascinating. The point was basically that while strikeouts by hitters are overemphasized, it is really, really hard to remain a productive player while striking out as ridiculously often as Reynolds does. And he went a long way toward proving that last year, going .198/.320/.433. I think he's an amazingly talented hitter and there's a good chance he turns it around, but I also think that in a division with Sabathia and Burnett and Lester and Beckett and Price, he could strike out 250 times. I'm going to forget all that and just hope that proximity to his alma mater (and mine, sort of), the University of Virginia, helps him somehow.
The Orioles are our second-to-last AL team to be questioned. They've made a bunch of fairly big moves this offseason, which you think would make them one of the more fun ones to talk about. You'd be wrong, though. Like, really wrong.
1. Is a good last-place team better than a bad last-place team?
Maybe that's not fair. PECOTA, after all, likes them to finish fourth, six games ahead of the Blue Jays. I just can't see it; the Jays have probably gotten a bit worse and the Orioles have gotten a bit better, but not to the tune of a 25-game swing from 2010.
The point, though, is that even that very rosy projection has the Orioles at 82-80 -- ten games out of first, nine out of a playoff spot, and stuck behind probably the three best teams in the league. So what are they doing acquiring three players -- Derrek Lee, Vladimir Guerrero and J.J. Hardy -- who will be free agents after this season? With those three guys, they've spent $21 million for, basically, a chance to move from a distant fifth place to a distant fourth.
And this is fun: a few days ago, GM Andy MacPhail was speaking to some law students when he said that Alex Rodriguez's huge 2001 contract with the Rangers was "the worst signing in the history of baseball in my view." And why? Because "the needle didn't move at all. The team didn't improve. Attendance didn't go up." MacPhail hasn't spent anywhere near A-Rod money this offseason, but it's hard to imagine these moves turning out any differently.
2. How Good Is Matt Wieters?
And speaking of PECOTA: in 2009, before he'd played a game in the big leagues, the system saw Wieters as putting up one of the greatest seasons a catcher has ever had: .311/.395/.544, with 31 home runs. Of course, that didn't happen, though he was about an average hitter in 2009, which in itself is impressive enough for a 23 year old catcher. But then he took a step back in 2010.
Wieters is still the same guy who was taken fifth overall in the draft, was the #1 prospect entering 2009, and hit an incredible .343/.438/.576 in his minor league career. We're still a couple years from being able to say he won't be a star in the major leagues. I get the sense people are writing him off already, but if you're going to bet on somebody to come up with a huge year out of nowhere this year (and its coming "out of nowhere" pretty much means you shouldn't bet on it, or whatever), Wieters would seem to be a pretty good choice.
3. Can Mark Reynolds Hit (in the AL East)?
I've written about Reynolds several times already (here and here and here), because he's fascinating. The point was basically that while strikeouts by hitters are overemphasized, it is really, really hard to remain a productive player while striking out as ridiculously often as Reynolds does. And he went a long way toward proving that last year, going .198/.320/.433. I think he's an amazingly talented hitter and there's a good chance he turns it around, but I also think that in a division with Sabathia and Burnett and Lester and Beckett and Price, he could strike out 250 times. I'm going to forget all that and just hope that proximity to his alma mater (and mine, sort of), the University of Virginia, helps him somehow.
Labels:
3 questions,
Baltimore Orioles,
baseball
TPA Hits ESPN on the SweetSpot
In case you missed us yesterday on ESPN's SweetSpot blog, here are handy links to our fine, fine work:
A Handy Guide to How Your Team Screwed Up This Off-Season
The Common Man takes you through the major kinds of errors we saw this offseason from different teams around the league.
What If Albert Pujols Really Does Leave the Cardinals?
The Common Man looks at how other teams have coped with the loss of the best player in baseball, and what that means for the Cards.
The Worst 100 RBI Seasons In Baseball History
Bill points out that 100 is just a nice round number, and it doesn't really tell you anything about a player's performance.
A Baseball Institution Turns 50!
The Common Man wishes happy birthday to Strat-o-Matic Baseball, which you should really play if you haven't already.
A Handy Guide to How Your Team Screwed Up This Off-Season
The Common Man takes you through the major kinds of errors we saw this offseason from different teams around the league.
What If Albert Pujols Really Does Leave the Cardinals?
The Common Man looks at how other teams have coped with the loss of the best player in baseball, and what that means for the Cards.
The Worst 100 RBI Seasons In Baseball History
Bill points out that 100 is just a nice round number, and it doesn't really tell you anything about a player's performance.
A Baseball Institution Turns 50!
The Common Man wishes happy birthday to Strat-o-Matic Baseball, which you should really play if you haven't already.
Labels:
baseball
The 40 Worst Off-Seasons: Part 2
Yesterday, The Common Man started his countdown of the 40 worst offseasons in baseball history. Part 1 is here. Part 3 is here. And Part 4 is here. Today, he continues, counting down from 30-21. Come along and enjoy the Pirates ridding themselves of two Hall of Famers, the Diamondbacks' disdain for MVP candidates, some of the worst free agent signings in baseball history, the Rays' false start, and the Twins giving away a Boston Icon for free. Remember, from yesterday, TCM is trying to "account for the Wins Above Replacement lost by each team over the next five years as a result of their actions, or (for modern teams) until a player traded away, waived, or released became a free agent again. He has also tried to account for teams whose terrible moves cost them postseason berths, and also for how fans likely felt if they were watching their team get gutted or flail about." And now, back to the rankings!
Labels:
40 Greatest,
off-seasons
Sunday, February 13, 2011
The 40 Worst Off-Seasons Ever, Part 1
By The Common Man
This list was inspired by a reader and Twins fan, Norm Steadman, who writes at Mister 70%. Norm has been understandably disappointed by Minnesota’s offseason so far, and wanted some way to feel better about their lackluster performance. To cheer Norm up, The Common Man thought he’d take him up on his suggestion to rank the 40 worst offseasons in baseball history. This is part 1. The series will be five parts long, and run every day this week, including some follow-up thoughts and conclusions on Friday. Good news, Norm, this iteration of the Twins are going to have to work really hard to crack this group.
Before we begin, a couple of notes. First, criteria. What makes a bad offseason? One thing, obviously, is when a team makes moves that hurt the team in either or both of the short or long term. Bad trades, bad signings. Things that cripple a franchise’s ability to compete. In his analysis, The Common Man has tried to account for the Wins Above Replacement lost by each team over the next five years as a result of their actions, or (for modern teams) until a player traded away, waived, or released became a free agent again. He has also tried to account for teams whose terrible moves cost them postseason berths, and also for how fans likely felt if they were watching their team get gutted or flail about.
Second, this is probably not a complete list, and TCM welcomes your suggestions for other teams that should be on here. TCM was working a lot from memory and from references like Rob Neyer’s Big Book of Baseball Blunders, but there is not a good systematic way to examine all the data without digging through roughly 2300 team-offseasons. If you’ve got ideas of other terrible offseasons, by all means suggest them in the comments.
Finally, the list does not include the rumors and expectations surrounding a team as part of the analysis. For instance, there were rumors once that Yankees and Red Sox were going to swap DiMaggio and Williams. That didn’t happen, and so TCM is not going to use it to analyze what could have happened during that offseason. Obviously, the level of disappointment fans may have had that an anticipated deal didn’t come together (like the Twins attempts to deal Johan Santana to the Yankees and Red Sox in 2008) would affect their perception of the offseason. But that’s not possible across history. So instead, The Common Man is sticking to what did happen. So let’s get started:
(Update: you can find part 2 here. Meanwhile, Part 3 is here. And Part 4 is up here.)
This list was inspired by a reader and Twins fan, Norm Steadman, who writes at Mister 70%. Norm has been understandably disappointed by Minnesota’s offseason so far, and wanted some way to feel better about their lackluster performance. To cheer Norm up, The Common Man thought he’d take him up on his suggestion to rank the 40 worst offseasons in baseball history. This is part 1. The series will be five parts long, and run every day this week, including some follow-up thoughts and conclusions on Friday. Good news, Norm, this iteration of the Twins are going to have to work really hard to crack this group.
Before we begin, a couple of notes. First, criteria. What makes a bad offseason? One thing, obviously, is when a team makes moves that hurt the team in either or both of the short or long term. Bad trades, bad signings. Things that cripple a franchise’s ability to compete. In his analysis, The Common Man has tried to account for the Wins Above Replacement lost by each team over the next five years as a result of their actions, or (for modern teams) until a player traded away, waived, or released became a free agent again. He has also tried to account for teams whose terrible moves cost them postseason berths, and also for how fans likely felt if they were watching their team get gutted or flail about.
Second, this is probably not a complete list, and TCM welcomes your suggestions for other teams that should be on here. TCM was working a lot from memory and from references like Rob Neyer’s Big Book of Baseball Blunders, but there is not a good systematic way to examine all the data without digging through roughly 2300 team-offseasons. If you’ve got ideas of other terrible offseasons, by all means suggest them in the comments.
Finally, the list does not include the rumors and expectations surrounding a team as part of the analysis. For instance, there were rumors once that Yankees and Red Sox were going to swap DiMaggio and Williams. That didn’t happen, and so TCM is not going to use it to analyze what could have happened during that offseason. Obviously, the level of disappointment fans may have had that an anticipated deal didn’t come together (like the Twins attempts to deal Johan Santana to the Yankees and Red Sox in 2008) would affect their perception of the offseason. But that’s not possible across history. So instead, The Common Man is sticking to what did happen. So let’s get started:
(Update: you can find part 2 here. Meanwhile, Part 3 is here. And Part 4 is up here.)
Labels:
40 Greatest,
baseball,
off-seasons
Thursday, February 10, 2011
Obligations
By The Common Man
Dammit, people, stop writing things The Common Man needs to respond to today. TCM is looking straight at you, Austin Swafford, mega-Astros fan, proprieter of Austin’s Astros 290 Blog on the SweetSpot Network and holder of the proverbial keys to the SweetSpot blog today:
Dammit, people, stop writing things The Common Man needs to respond to today. TCM is looking straight at you, Austin Swafford, mega-Astros fan, proprieter of Austin’s Astros 290 Blog on the SweetSpot Network and holder of the proverbial keys to the SweetSpot blog today:
“Are the Rangers the only ones who were surprised by this? Were even the Rangers surprised? [Michael] Young has become the face of the Rangers and has been a model citizen, but you can only push a guy so far, and it's been going on with him for years. Granted, he's been paid well for what he's done with the Rangers. But it's nice to feel like the team is behind you, respects you and views you as an important piece of their success. Young's contributions for a decade have certainly warranted Texas' respect.”How have the Rangers disrespected “the face of the franchise?” Well, Austin takes Young at his word that he’s been "misled and manipulated on different occasions." And as evidence of this, Austin points out that the Rangers have “taken advantage of his versatility and willingness” and asked/cajoled him to switch positions. This after making him the face of the franchise in the first place. And after making him one of the highest paid players in Major League Baseball. Both of which are excellent ways to show a ballplayer respect.
Labels:
baseball,
Michael Young,
Texas Rangers
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)