By Bill (with able commentary from The Common Man)
It feels weird to even type those years in this post's title. By the time this comes to pass, I plan to be the mostly benevolent (but very volatile) dictator of a small planet in the Alpha Centauri system, and I'll start my own damn baseball organization. It'll have two eight-team leagues, the Mack League and the Stieb League, with the DH and replay everywhere. It will be glorious.
But while we're all still tethered to this particular orb, we might as well look at what Hall of Fame voting might be like 11 to 15 years from now. We're covering the next 25 years of the writers' HOF voting, just like Bill James did back in '94. You can see Part 1 here and Part 2 here. The Common Man and I each came up with our own separate (and very different) lists, and the middle fifth of those lists is dissected below. (Here are the other entries in our series, Part 1, Part 2, Part 4, and Part 5, as well as our wrap-up.)
Wednesday, February 23, 2011
Tuesday, February 22, 2011
TPA Hits ESPN on the SweetSpot, Part 2
Yesterday, in addition to starting our Hall of Fame voting projections, we had five articles up over at The SweetSpot on ESPN.com. In case you missed them, the links and a brief description are below. Feel free to peruse them at your leisure.
Hall of Fame Should Lower the Voting Threshold
To deal with the upcoming backlog of candidates, Bill and TCM argue convincingly for the election threshold to drop from 75% to 66%.
Jose Bautista's Win-Win Deal
The Common Man is pretty bullish on Bautista's new deal, from both his perspective and that of the Blue Jays.
More on Jim Edmonds and the Hall
Bill makes the case for Jim Edmonds, which will be largely ignored by the voters in five years.
On Michael Young and Fandom
TCM tackles the notion that Young has somehow been "wronged" by the Rangers.
People Still Don't Get Moneyball
It's been close to a decade since that book came out, and as Bill points out, too many writers are still getting it wrong and oblivious to the lessons it teaches.
Hall of Fame Should Lower the Voting Threshold
To deal with the upcoming backlog of candidates, Bill and TCM argue convincingly for the election threshold to drop from 75% to 66%.
Jose Bautista's Win-Win Deal
The Common Man is pretty bullish on Bautista's new deal, from both his perspective and that of the Blue Jays.
More on Jim Edmonds and the Hall
Bill makes the case for Jim Edmonds, which will be largely ignored by the voters in five years.
On Michael Young and Fandom
TCM tackles the notion that Young has somehow been "wronged" by the Rangers.
People Still Don't Get Moneyball
It's been close to a decade since that book came out, and as Bill points out, too many writers are still getting it wrong and oblivious to the lessons it teaches.
Labels:
baseball,
us elsewhere
Predicting the Hall of Fame Votes, Part 2: 2017-2021
By The Common Man (undermined at every turn by Bill)
Yesterday, Bill kicked us off with the first installment of this series, in which we're picking the BBWAA Hall of Fame voting results from the next 25 years. Yesterday, out of 13 players mentioned, we agreed on 10 of them going in in that five year window, though our order was somewhat different. As we move further out though, we're going to start to see a lot more distance between Bill's predictions and The Common Man's. (Here are the other entries in our series, Part 1, Part 3, Part 4, and Part 5, as well as our wrap-up.)
Here's our methodology, as outlined by Bill yesterday,
Yesterday, Bill kicked us off with the first installment of this series, in which we're picking the BBWAA Hall of Fame voting results from the next 25 years. Yesterday, out of 13 players mentioned, we agreed on 10 of them going in in that five year window, though our order was somewhat different. As we move further out though, we're going to start to see a lot more distance between Bill's predictions and The Common Man's. (Here are the other entries in our series, Part 1, Part 3, Part 4, and Part 5, as well as our wrap-up.)
Here's our methodology, as outlined by Bill yesterday,
"James picked two inductees for every season, which makes sense; historically, there have been either one or two BBWAA inductees in virtually every year, and since it's almost entirely guesswork anyway, why not make it uniform? But on the other hand, there are a ton of worthy candidates coming up, and you do see three in a class about once every ten years (see 1984, 1991, 1999). So we decided to limit ourselves to two candidates (or fewer, though I chose never to pick fewer) in every year, with the exception of two seasons, in which we could name three. For a 25-year stretch, that seems reasonable."We both used up our three-man ballots yesterday, so those are off the table. The Common Man is handling the main commentary this time, with Bill piping up whenever he feels like it. And away we go:
Labels:
baseball,
Bill James,
hall of fame,
HOF projection series
SweetSpot Roundup 2/22
Austin's Astros 290 Blog: Friday Optimism
And now you get it on a Tuesday! "Why not be optimistic? I’m as frustrated as the next fan, but you know…if I can’t be optimistic now, I might not ever have the chance."
Capitol Avenue Club (Braves): Andy Marte - Learning our lesson
Kevin looks back at a set of unpopular Braves moves that didn't turn out quite as badly as everyone expected, and along the way unearths some pretty funny quotes about uber-prospect Marte.
Fungoes (Cardinals): With Lohse, time is right for Cardinals to try four-man rotation
Several years ago (I don't remember now, 2002 or so?), a popular thought among sabermetricians -- then much less popular people -- was that five-man rotations were silly, that it was pitches per start, not days between starts, that fatigued a pitcher, and that teams would be heading toward four-man rotations in the near future. I never saw any study that contradicted that thought, or anything...it just kind of went away. Well, Pip looks at the Cardinals' four very good starters on one hand, and Kyle Lohse on the other, and figures it's time to start banging that drum again.
The View from the Bleachers (Cubs): The Soriano Experiment
As we enter year five (!) of that huge, predictably poor contract Jim Hendry signed Alfonso Soriano to, Buddy finds it a good time to take stock.
Dodger Thoughts: Now Batting, Don Mattingly
Quotes about Manager Donnie standing in in the batter's box for bullpen sessions, and other Spring Training Dodger news.
Mets Today: Is Terry Collins Detached from Reality, or Playing Head Games?
Joe muses about some really puzzling things the new Met manager had to say to or about Luis Castillo.
Nationals Baseball: Danny Espinosa, I do not know you.
"As far as the Nats offense goes I feel like I got a pretty good grasp on how almost everyone is going to do. Those with a lot of major league experience (Werth, Zimm, The French Rock) are easy enough to predict. I think Morgan and Desmond will fall nicely into "better than last year, still not as good as fans hope". Pudge will have an empty batting average and stink. Ramos will have an empty batting average and not stink. But Danny Espinosa eludes me."
Ducksnorts (Padres): I think I sprained my cliche
Geoff with an entertainingly snarky look at some of the things to keep an eye on this spring.
Crashburn Alley (Phillies): Marlins 2011 Preview with Michael Jong
Getting the skinny on one of the Phillies' division rivals, from one of my favorite non-SweetSpot bloggers.
Redleg Nation: Behind the Plate
Thoughts on the catcher position, where the Reds are in much better shape than you probably realize. I'm with Chad, though -- if Ramon Hernandez is okay and everything, but if Hanigan's healthy, Hanigan's your catcher.
Baseballin' on a Budget (A's): Shooty Babitt, the King of the Parlay
An interesting interview with one of the A's broadcasters, who spent just a single year in the Bigs.
Ghostrunner on First (Blue Jays): Don't Lose Sight
It's nice to know that Drew is just as bullish on the Bautista deal as I am.
Pro Ball NW (Mariners): Get Excited About Josh Lueke
Lueke is, of course, the young pitcher who was guilty of wrongfully imprisoning a young woman in 2008 and had sex with her while she was passed out and who refers to the violent rape and sodomization of a woman as "a situtation that I shouldn't have [gotten into]. Used poor judgment." Get excited about him all you want. I hope he falls down an open manhole and breaks his femur and pelvis in several places. And if he landed on his shoulder, that'd be all right too. I don't give a damn how "severely underrated" he is.
Baseball Time in Arlington (Rangers): Michael Young (and the Rangers) Discuss the Trade Situation
The Rangers and Michael Young continue to need to walk back from his comments over the offseason and the team's failed attempts to deal him.
The Ray Area: Don't Go to the Spring Training Zoo
Marc is underwhelmed by the actual process of visiting Spring Training.
Fire Brand of the American League (Red Sox): Should We Count the Yankees Out?
The answer, of course, is no. You don't count the Yankees out until you kill them, bury them, dig them up to make sure they're still dead, drive a stake through their heart just to make sure, and throw the body in a wood chipper like in Fargo.
Royals Authority: The Future of Catching
Craig profiles Kansas City's catcher of the future, Salvador Perez. Sounds flashy.
The Daily Fungo (Tigers): Sheff Checks Out
"There’s been no other Tigers player in my lifetime that has left me wanting more than Sheff."
Nick's Twins Blog: Liriano and Work Ethic
"If quotes like the one Anderson provided above accurately reflect the lefty's work ethic, it's hard to fault the club for being hesitant to commit long-term, or for being perpetually irritated when apparently avoidable injury issues like his current shoulder soreness crop up."
It's About the Money, Stupid (Yankees): Could Brackman Be the Fifth Starter?
Has it really gotten this desperate in the Bronx?
And now you get it on a Tuesday! "Why not be optimistic? I’m as frustrated as the next fan, but you know…if I can’t be optimistic now, I might not ever have the chance."
Capitol Avenue Club (Braves): Andy Marte - Learning our lesson
Kevin looks back at a set of unpopular Braves moves that didn't turn out quite as badly as everyone expected, and along the way unearths some pretty funny quotes about uber-prospect Marte.
Fungoes (Cardinals): With Lohse, time is right for Cardinals to try four-man rotation
Several years ago (I don't remember now, 2002 or so?), a popular thought among sabermetricians -- then much less popular people -- was that five-man rotations were silly, that it was pitches per start, not days between starts, that fatigued a pitcher, and that teams would be heading toward four-man rotations in the near future. I never saw any study that contradicted that thought, or anything...it just kind of went away. Well, Pip looks at the Cardinals' four very good starters on one hand, and Kyle Lohse on the other, and figures it's time to start banging that drum again.
The View from the Bleachers (Cubs): The Soriano Experiment
As we enter year five (!) of that huge, predictably poor contract Jim Hendry signed Alfonso Soriano to, Buddy finds it a good time to take stock.
Dodger Thoughts: Now Batting, Don Mattingly
Quotes about Manager Donnie standing in in the batter's box for bullpen sessions, and other Spring Training Dodger news.
Mets Today: Is Terry Collins Detached from Reality, or Playing Head Games?
Joe muses about some really puzzling things the new Met manager had to say to or about Luis Castillo.
Nationals Baseball: Danny Espinosa, I do not know you.
"As far as the Nats offense goes I feel like I got a pretty good grasp on how almost everyone is going to do. Those with a lot of major league experience (Werth, Zimm, The French Rock) are easy enough to predict. I think Morgan and Desmond will fall nicely into "better than last year, still not as good as fans hope". Pudge will have an empty batting average and stink. Ramos will have an empty batting average and not stink. But Danny Espinosa eludes me."
Ducksnorts (Padres): I think I sprained my cliche
Geoff with an entertainingly snarky look at some of the things to keep an eye on this spring.
Crashburn Alley (Phillies): Marlins 2011 Preview with Michael Jong
Getting the skinny on one of the Phillies' division rivals, from one of my favorite non-SweetSpot bloggers.
Redleg Nation: Behind the Plate
Thoughts on the catcher position, where the Reds are in much better shape than you probably realize. I'm with Chad, though -- if Ramon Hernandez is okay and everything, but if Hanigan's healthy, Hanigan's your catcher.
Baseballin' on a Budget (A's): Shooty Babitt, the King of the Parlay
An interesting interview with one of the A's broadcasters, who spent just a single year in the Bigs.
Ghostrunner on First (Blue Jays): Don't Lose Sight
It's nice to know that Drew is just as bullish on the Bautista deal as I am.
Pro Ball NW (Mariners): Get Excited About Josh Lueke
Lueke is, of course, the young pitcher who was guilty of wrongfully imprisoning a young woman in 2008 and had sex with her while she was passed out and who refers to the violent rape and sodomization of a woman as "a situtation that I shouldn't have [gotten into]. Used poor judgment." Get excited about him all you want. I hope he falls down an open manhole and breaks his femur and pelvis in several places. And if he landed on his shoulder, that'd be all right too. I don't give a damn how "severely underrated" he is.
Baseball Time in Arlington (Rangers): Michael Young (and the Rangers) Discuss the Trade Situation
The Rangers and Michael Young continue to need to walk back from his comments over the offseason and the team's failed attempts to deal him.
The Ray Area: Don't Go to the Spring Training Zoo
Marc is underwhelmed by the actual process of visiting Spring Training.
Fire Brand of the American League (Red Sox): Should We Count the Yankees Out?
The answer, of course, is no. You don't count the Yankees out until you kill them, bury them, dig them up to make sure they're still dead, drive a stake through their heart just to make sure, and throw the body in a wood chipper like in Fargo.
Royals Authority: The Future of Catching
Craig profiles Kansas City's catcher of the future, Salvador Perez. Sounds flashy.
The Daily Fungo (Tigers): Sheff Checks Out
"There’s been no other Tigers player in my lifetime that has left me wanting more than Sheff."
Nick's Twins Blog: Liriano and Work Ethic
"If quotes like the one Anderson provided above accurately reflect the lefty's work ethic, it's hard to fault the club for being hesitant to commit long-term, or for being perpetually irritated when apparently avoidable injury issues like his current shoulder soreness crop up."
It's About the Money, Stupid (Yankees): Could Brackman Be the Fifth Starter?
Has it really gotten this desperate in the Bronx?
Labels:
baseball,
SweetSpot Roundup
Sunday, February 20, 2011
Predicting the Hall of Fame Votes, Part I: 2012-2016
By Bill (with special guest snarking from The Common Man)
You might remember that a little over a month ago, I wrote about Bill James' 1994 predictions for the BBWAA Hall of Fame voting covering the next 25 years: 1995-2019.
I had a lot of (respectful) fun pointing out James' hits and misses, in what was essentially an impossible exercise, so TCM and I thought it only fair to try the same impossible exercise ourselves. We've each made our own lists covering the next 25 years of BBWAA voting -- 2012-2036 -- and as you'll see, our lists are very different, even as to players who have already retired (I can't wait to see what happens when we're dealing with guys currently in their early twenties). We'll be unveiling and discussing our lists in five five-year segments in the coming days and/or weeks. Today, the immediate next five years, 2012-2016, which covers the first ballot for every player who has already retired (2010 retirees will be eligible in 2016). (Also, here is Part 2, Part 3, Part 4, and Part 5, as well as our wrap-up).
A word on methodology. James picked two inductees for every season, which makes sense; historically, there have been either one or two BBWAA inductees in virtually every year, and since it's almost entirely guesswork anyway, why not make it uniform? But on the other hand, there are a ton of worthy candidates coming up, and you do see three in a class about once every ten years (see 1984, 1991, 1999). So we decided to limit ourselves to two candidates (or fewer, though I chose never to pick fewer) in every year, with the exception of two seasons, in which we could name three. For a 25-year stretch, that seems reasonable.
So, onward. I'm handling the main commentary this time, with TCM injecting comments as he sees fit, and we'll switch next time. Here's hoping that in fifteen years, someone will care enough about us to come back to this list and have a good laugh at our expense:
You might remember that a little over a month ago, I wrote about Bill James' 1994 predictions for the BBWAA Hall of Fame voting covering the next 25 years: 1995-2019.
I had a lot of (respectful) fun pointing out James' hits and misses, in what was essentially an impossible exercise, so TCM and I thought it only fair to try the same impossible exercise ourselves. We've each made our own lists covering the next 25 years of BBWAA voting -- 2012-2036 -- and as you'll see, our lists are very different, even as to players who have already retired (I can't wait to see what happens when we're dealing with guys currently in their early twenties). We'll be unveiling and discussing our lists in five five-year segments in the coming days and/or weeks. Today, the immediate next five years, 2012-2016, which covers the first ballot for every player who has already retired (2010 retirees will be eligible in 2016). (Also, here is Part 2, Part 3, Part 4, and Part 5, as well as our wrap-up).
A word on methodology. James picked two inductees for every season, which makes sense; historically, there have been either one or two BBWAA inductees in virtually every year, and since it's almost entirely guesswork anyway, why not make it uniform? But on the other hand, there are a ton of worthy candidates coming up, and you do see three in a class about once every ten years (see 1984, 1991, 1999). So we decided to limit ourselves to two candidates (or fewer, though I chose never to pick fewer) in every year, with the exception of two seasons, in which we could name three. For a 25-year stretch, that seems reasonable.
So, onward. I'm handling the main commentary this time, with TCM injecting comments as he sees fit, and we'll switch next time. Here's hoping that in fifteen years, someone will care enough about us to come back to this list and have a good laugh at our expense:
Labels:
baseball,
Bill James,
hall of fame,
HOF projection series
Thursday, February 17, 2011
The 40 Worst Off-Seasons Ever, Part 4
This week, The Common Man has been counting down the 40 worst offseasons in baseball history. Part 1 is here. Part 2 is here. And part 3 is here. Today, he concludes, counting down from 10-1. Today, the Marlins and A's hold fire sales, the Giants petulently throw away a pennant, the Red Sox make the single most disasterous team that a team could make, even worse than the Mets, except for the one made by the Astros. Remember, from yesterday, TCM is trying to "account for the Wins Above Replacement lost by each team over the next five years as a result of their actions, or (for modern teams) until a player traded away, waived, or released became a free agent again. He has also tried to account for teams whose terrible moves cost them postseason berths, and also for how fans likely felt if they were watching their team get gutted or flail about." And now,the rest of the rankings!
Labels:
40 Greatest,
baseball,
baseball history,
off-seasons
3 Questions: Seattle Mariners
By Bill
OK, so I was one of those people who thought the Mariners were in really, really good shape at about this time last year. Every single move they made made sense, at least in isolation. And in retrospect, they certainly needed to do more -- in particular, a first baseman who could do more than play defense would have helped -- but I still think it should have been pretty good. I never picked them to win the division (or at least I don't think I did...please don't look it up), but I certainly didn't see 61-101 coming, and I think anyone who says he or she did is a liar. Any reason to hope for anything more this year?
1. Have they improved at all?
Last year, Jack Zduriencik was the busiest GM of the offseason, pretty much from start to finish. This offseason, you barely heard anything from the M's at all...which is what tends to happen with 100-loss teams who don't have a superstar to sell off. Moves were made, though. Jack Cust is in, Russell Branyan is out. Jose Lopez is gone, with Brendan Ryan, however temporarily, taking his place.
So that's not much, but on the other hand, there are a lot of guys who really can't be as bad as they were in 2010. Figgins, in particular (assuming he isn't traded), isn't the near-MVP candidate he was in 2009, but he had the worst year of his career in 2010, and he's not that guy either. Ryan certainly isn't quite the offensive zero he was in 2010, it's unlikely Milton Bradley has completely forgotten to hit, and so on. If the M's hadn't done anything at all, they'd very likely be better, just through regression and better luck.
And it's not just the dreadful offense that sunk them last year. The defense took a big step back, too, from close to the best in the game in 2009 to something like the middle of the pack in '10. Moving Figgins from second back to third, where he seems to perform much better, a healthy Jack Wilson, and plugging in the excellent Ryan for the plodding Lopez should all help. People will tell you that they need offense, not defense, to win. I don't buy it; until the point where their defense and pitching combine to allow 0.0 runs per game, permitting fewer runs will help them win roughly as much as scoring more runs will.
Baseball Prospectus' AL West preview went up yesterday, and PECOTA sees the Mariners going 68-94 (with some really dryly funny commentary from Mr. Wyers). For the second post in a row, I just can't buy that. That's a seven-game improvement over 2010 (and a nine-game improvement over their 2010 Pythagorean record), but between their being better and the Rangers and Angels being worse, 75 or so wins seems to me like a better bet.
OK, so I was one of those people who thought the Mariners were in really, really good shape at about this time last year. Every single move they made made sense, at least in isolation. And in retrospect, they certainly needed to do more -- in particular, a first baseman who could do more than play defense would have helped -- but I still think it should have been pretty good. I never picked them to win the division (or at least I don't think I did...please don't look it up), but I certainly didn't see 61-101 coming, and I think anyone who says he or she did is a liar. Any reason to hope for anything more this year?
1. Have they improved at all?
Last year, Jack Zduriencik was the busiest GM of the offseason, pretty much from start to finish. This offseason, you barely heard anything from the M's at all...which is what tends to happen with 100-loss teams who don't have a superstar to sell off. Moves were made, though. Jack Cust is in, Russell Branyan is out. Jose Lopez is gone, with Brendan Ryan, however temporarily, taking his place.
So that's not much, but on the other hand, there are a lot of guys who really can't be as bad as they were in 2010. Figgins, in particular (assuming he isn't traded), isn't the near-MVP candidate he was in 2009, but he had the worst year of his career in 2010, and he's not that guy either. Ryan certainly isn't quite the offensive zero he was in 2010, it's unlikely Milton Bradley has completely forgotten to hit, and so on. If the M's hadn't done anything at all, they'd very likely be better, just through regression and better luck.
And it's not just the dreadful offense that sunk them last year. The defense took a big step back, too, from close to the best in the game in 2009 to something like the middle of the pack in '10. Moving Figgins from second back to third, where he seems to perform much better, a healthy Jack Wilson, and plugging in the excellent Ryan for the plodding Lopez should all help. People will tell you that they need offense, not defense, to win. I don't buy it; until the point where their defense and pitching combine to allow 0.0 runs per game, permitting fewer runs will help them win roughly as much as scoring more runs will.
Baseball Prospectus' AL West preview went up yesterday, and PECOTA sees the Mariners going 68-94 (with some really dryly funny commentary from Mr. Wyers). For the second post in a row, I just can't buy that. That's a seven-game improvement over 2010 (and a nine-game improvement over their 2010 Pythagorean record), but between their being better and the Rangers and Angels being worse, 75 or so wins seems to me like a better bet.
Labels:
3 questions,
baseball,
Seattle Mariners
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)