By Bill
So last week, The Common Man and I took on the daunting and ultimately pretty silly task of predicting how the next 25 years of BBWAA Hall of Fame voting would go. The five-part set of summaries is right here (1, 2, 3, 4, 5), and now, you can see all the results together in an ugly little spreadsheet here.
I picked 52 inductees, and TCM picked 51. Forty names appear on both of our lists, which you could look at a few different ways -- either 77.7% of the total names matched (80/103), or 63.5% of the players picked were picked by both of us (40/63). The second way is probably more meaningful, but either way, it seems to me like quite a lot of agreement for something this wide open. On the chart linked above, the players who were picked by only one of us are highlighted in red.
On the other hand, there are 18 players (28.6% of the total players or 35% of all our picks) who we not only both picked, but both picked to go in in the same year. These come primarily in the first several years, as you might guess -- Biggio, Maddux, and Griffey are the easy ones -- but there were some pretty random agreements down the road, too. Most notably, we both have Mauer and Sabathia going in in 2026 somehow, and we both picked Buster Posey for 2032 and Jason Heyward for '35. All those perfect matches are highlighted in yellow.
Here's a look at some of the key players we disagreed on, followed by some players we skipped completely:
Tuesday, March 1, 2011
SweetSpot Roundup 3/1
Capitol Avenue Club (Braves): Baseball Returns
Peter's got the recap of the Braves' first spring action, including a big day by NL ROY favorite Freddie Freeman.
Disciples of Uecker (Brewers): Yuniesky Betancourt Displays Plate Discipline
Jack hopes against hope that the trade to the Brewers has inspired Yuni to admit to himself that he doesn't always have to swing the bat.
The View From the Bleachers (Cubs): Game Notes - 2/27
Joe reacts to the first Spring game for the Cubbies.
Dodger Thoughts: Dodgers win with pitching, hitting and no defense
A good Spring start for the Dodgers is marred by the sad loss of Duke Snider.
Bay City Ball (Giants): Oh yeah, Mark DeRosa
It's easy to forget the Giants might have one of the best 10th men in baseball this year.
Mets Today: Ollie, a Year Ago
It's been about a year since the full disaster that is Oliver Perez became fully understood. And he's got roughly 10 days left to save his career.
Nationals Baseball: Twelve-Sided Bryce
Happy Bryce Harper Day! Oh, he struck out twice on 7 pitches. Hmm...not so good.
Ducksnorts (Padres): Has It Started Yet?
Indeed, it has. Geoff reacts to the first action of the Spring.
Crashburn Alley (Phillies): Albert Pujols Is Not a Fit in Philadelphia
Bill puts to bed the idiotic rumor that the Cardinals would deal Albert Pujols for Ryan Howard and Joe Blanton.
Redleg Nation: Reds talking extension with Brandon Phillips
"Even if you believe the Reds should keep Phillips, I don’t see how it makes fiscal sense for this team or how it’s possible. They just invested big money in Votto, Bruce, Arroyo, and Cueto AND have a multi-year deal on the table with Volquez."
Baseballin' on a Budget (Athletics): Top Fives: Best Left-Handed Starting Pitchers in Team History
This one's a pretty great list -- three Hall of Famers and two Cy Young winners. As I've written before (in response to other pieces in this series), it's kind of amazing how quickly lists like this tend to thin out, but this is a good one.
Ghostrunner on First (Blue Jays): Introducing the ISO Challenge
"Both [Rajai] Davis & [Yunel] Escobar figure to post isolated power numbers right around the .100 mark. When league average is around .160, these two are staring Punch and/or Judy status right in the face."
Pro Ball NW (Mariners): Appreciating Felix Hernandez
"There are certain things in life you can count on, like zany interviews and cultural oddities from Ichiro Suzuki. There are things you can’t count on, like for Dustin Ackley to be great as soon as he steps on a Major League diamond. And there are things you can count on not counting on, like Érik Bédard’s health. Felix Hernandez is a man you can count on to be fantastic at what he does, almost every time he goes about doing it."
Baseball Time in Arlington (Rangers): Monday Morning Rangers Notes: 101s and Heartbreak
Gotta be honest: I'm either not seeing the "heartbreak" or I'm missing the reference entirely. But there is plenty of prospect and injury news.
Fire Brand of the AL (Red Sox): The Ho-Hum Mr. Marco Scutaro
...or is he? (Hint: well yeah, but he's actually pretty good.) But more importantly, Pokey Reese was a fan favorite in Boston? Really? Wow.
Royals Authority: Seriously Zeroing In on 25
The last monthly estimate of what the Opening Day roster will look like before we finally know what the Opening Day roster looks like.
Nick's Twins Blog: Success vs. Failure
A really good point by Nick about how our fanhood affects the way we interpret the things we see on the field.
It's About the Money, Stupid (Yankees): Joba or Nova for Liriano?
Presented without comment for mental health reasons.
Peter's got the recap of the Braves' first spring action, including a big day by NL ROY favorite Freddie Freeman.
Disciples of Uecker (Brewers): Yuniesky Betancourt Displays Plate Discipline
Jack hopes against hope that the trade to the Brewers has inspired Yuni to admit to himself that he doesn't always have to swing the bat.
The View From the Bleachers (Cubs): Game Notes - 2/27
Joe reacts to the first Spring game for the Cubbies.
Dodger Thoughts: Dodgers win with pitching, hitting and no defense
A good Spring start for the Dodgers is marred by the sad loss of Duke Snider.
Bay City Ball (Giants): Oh yeah, Mark DeRosa
It's easy to forget the Giants might have one of the best 10th men in baseball this year.
Mets Today: Ollie, a Year Ago
It's been about a year since the full disaster that is Oliver Perez became fully understood. And he's got roughly 10 days left to save his career.
Nationals Baseball: Twelve-Sided Bryce
Happy Bryce Harper Day! Oh, he struck out twice on 7 pitches. Hmm...not so good.
Ducksnorts (Padres): Has It Started Yet?
Indeed, it has. Geoff reacts to the first action of the Spring.
Crashburn Alley (Phillies): Albert Pujols Is Not a Fit in Philadelphia
Bill puts to bed the idiotic rumor that the Cardinals would deal Albert Pujols for Ryan Howard and Joe Blanton.
Redleg Nation: Reds talking extension with Brandon Phillips
"Even if you believe the Reds should keep Phillips, I don’t see how it makes fiscal sense for this team or how it’s possible. They just invested big money in Votto, Bruce, Arroyo, and Cueto AND have a multi-year deal on the table with Volquez."
Baseballin' on a Budget (Athletics): Top Fives: Best Left-Handed Starting Pitchers in Team History
This one's a pretty great list -- three Hall of Famers and two Cy Young winners. As I've written before (in response to other pieces in this series), it's kind of amazing how quickly lists like this tend to thin out, but this is a good one.
Ghostrunner on First (Blue Jays): Introducing the ISO Challenge
"Both [Rajai] Davis & [Yunel] Escobar figure to post isolated power numbers right around the .100 mark. When league average is around .160, these two are staring Punch and/or Judy status right in the face."
Pro Ball NW (Mariners): Appreciating Felix Hernandez
"There are certain things in life you can count on, like zany interviews and cultural oddities from Ichiro Suzuki. There are things you can’t count on, like for Dustin Ackley to be great as soon as he steps on a Major League diamond. And there are things you can count on not counting on, like Érik Bédard’s health. Felix Hernandez is a man you can count on to be fantastic at what he does, almost every time he goes about doing it."
Baseball Time in Arlington (Rangers): Monday Morning Rangers Notes: 101s and Heartbreak
Gotta be honest: I'm either not seeing the "heartbreak" or I'm missing the reference entirely. But there is plenty of prospect and injury news.
Fire Brand of the AL (Red Sox): The Ho-Hum Mr. Marco Scutaro
...or is he? (Hint: well yeah, but he's actually pretty good.) But more importantly, Pokey Reese was a fan favorite in Boston? Really? Wow.
Royals Authority: Seriously Zeroing In on 25
The last monthly estimate of what the Opening Day roster will look like before we finally know what the Opening Day roster looks like.
Nick's Twins Blog: Success vs. Failure
A really good point by Nick about how our fanhood affects the way we interpret the things we see on the field.
It's About the Money, Stupid (Yankees): Joba or Nova for Liriano?
Presented without comment for mental health reasons.
Labels:
baseball,
SweetSpot Roundup
Friday, February 25, 2011
The Padres will be better than you and Vegas thinks
By The Common Man
Aside from The Common Man, who praised the Padres to the heavens for their offseason moves here and here, the conversation from the national media has largely dismissed the San Diego Padres, given that they traded superstar Adrian Gonzalez to the Red Sox this offseason. Jayson Stark gave them an C, for instance. And now, according to the Vegas sports books (h/t to Aaron Gleeman), the San Diego Padres are going to finish with somewhere around 76 wins. Frankly, that’s a bet you should take. And take the over. Here’s why:
Aside from The Common Man, who praised the Padres to the heavens for their offseason moves here and here, the conversation from the national media has largely dismissed the San Diego Padres, given that they traded superstar Adrian Gonzalez to the Red Sox this offseason. Jayson Stark gave them an C, for instance. And now, according to the Vegas sports books (h/t to Aaron Gleeman), the San Diego Padres are going to finish with somewhere around 76 wins. Frankly, that’s a bet you should take. And take the over. Here’s why:
Labels:
baseball,
San Diego Padres
SweetSpot Roundup 2/25
Capitol Avenue Club (Braves): The '11 Braves--Baserunning
Peter says that the Braves' bad baserunning will, if everything breaks right, cost them only about half a win this season.
Disciples of Uecker (Brewers): LaTroy Hawkins Should Fit In New Role
As long as that role doesn't involve Twitter, it should be good. I'm following LaTroy, and let me tell you, it's been brutal. All inspirational messages. Good for him, by the way, for being so positive. But it's tough on cynical bloggers like me who want some context and personality.
Fungoes (Cardinals): Managing tactic for the 2011 Cardinals?
Cards bloggers discuss what tricky tactics they'd most like to see Tony LaRussa employ this year.
The View From the Bleachers (Cubs): Lose a prime Piece of Your Rotation? Call Jim Hendry!!
Joe generously offers some of his team's excess starters to the Cards to replace Adam Wainwright
Dodgers Thoughts: With Padilla out, who is the Dodgers' No. 6 starter?
Jon Weisman runs through the backup options for the Dodgers' backup option.
Bay City Ball (Giants): Name That Mystery Player
Chris finds an interesting comp for Pablo Sandoval. That comp has never been photographed like this, however.
Mets Today: Offseason Changes: Phillies
Joe runs through the chances of the scariest team in the NL East.
Nationals Baseball: Anyone hear anything about Bryce Harper?
Harper takes us through the ups and downs of the Bryce Harper Hype Machine, which Jon Heyman is official on.
Ducksnorts (Padres): Regardless of Venue, Homers Are Hard to Come By in San Diego
No matter the ballpark, the Padres just can't seem to hit homers in San Diego.
Redleg Nation (Reds): Oh Jonny
Did he or did he not sing about Wainwright's injury? Chad Dotson break it down.
Crashburn Alley (Phillies): Potential Phillies Lineups
Who's going to bat where for the Phils? And does it actually matter?
Ghostrunner on First (Blue Jays): Projectin' Thangs-Pitchers
Drew ponders the very optimistic projections for Blue Jays pitchers.
Pro Ball NW (Mariners): Bradley vs. Saunders
Would the Mariners actually consider giving LF back to Milton Bradley? Masochists.
Weaver's Tantrum (Orioles): Roberts' Neck
The O's shots at respectability will take a tumble if Brian Roberts' neck doesn't heal.
Baseball Time in Arlington (Rangers): The Crucible
How hard is it to be above replacement level? Prashanth Francis does some cool math, makes some charts, and comes up with the answer.
The Ray Area: Did I invent a time machine?
Mark understandably goes off on Ken Rosenthal's suggestion that baseball may revisit contraction, and that the Rays could be on the chopping block.
Fire Brand of the American League (Red Sox): Red Sox Shut Down Doubront
The Red Sox are taking the conservative route with their young starter.
Royals Authority: Rewind Yourself
Craig Brown breaks down the seriously deranged diatribe that Jason Kendall laid down this week.
The Daily Fungo: Tigers Podcast 128
In which Mike touches on the Miguel Cabreara situation and the 2B competition.
Nick's Twins Blog: Span's Grounders Must Get Moving
How can Denard Span turn it around after a disappointing 2010?
It's About the Money, Stupid (Yankees): It's Not Personal Sonny, It's Strictly Business
Brien takes Mitch Williams to task for his idiotic and immature take on the Rangers/Michael Young situation.
Peter says that the Braves' bad baserunning will, if everything breaks right, cost them only about half a win this season.
Disciples of Uecker (Brewers): LaTroy Hawkins Should Fit In New Role
As long as that role doesn't involve Twitter, it should be good. I'm following LaTroy, and let me tell you, it's been brutal. All inspirational messages. Good for him, by the way, for being so positive. But it's tough on cynical bloggers like me who want some context and personality.
Fungoes (Cardinals): Managing tactic for the 2011 Cardinals?
Cards bloggers discuss what tricky tactics they'd most like to see Tony LaRussa employ this year.
The View From the Bleachers (Cubs): Lose a prime Piece of Your Rotation? Call Jim Hendry!!
Joe generously offers some of his team's excess starters to the Cards to replace Adam Wainwright
Dodgers Thoughts: With Padilla out, who is the Dodgers' No. 6 starter?
Jon Weisman runs through the backup options for the Dodgers' backup option.
Bay City Ball (Giants): Name That Mystery Player
Chris finds an interesting comp for Pablo Sandoval. That comp has never been photographed like this, however.
Mets Today: Offseason Changes: Phillies
Joe runs through the chances of the scariest team in the NL East.
Nationals Baseball: Anyone hear anything about Bryce Harper?
Harper takes us through the ups and downs of the Bryce Harper Hype Machine, which Jon Heyman is official on.
Ducksnorts (Padres): Regardless of Venue, Homers Are Hard to Come By in San Diego
No matter the ballpark, the Padres just can't seem to hit homers in San Diego.
Redleg Nation (Reds): Oh Jonny
Did he or did he not sing about Wainwright's injury? Chad Dotson break it down.
Crashburn Alley (Phillies): Potential Phillies Lineups
Who's going to bat where for the Phils? And does it actually matter?
Ghostrunner on First (Blue Jays): Projectin' Thangs-Pitchers
Drew ponders the very optimistic projections for Blue Jays pitchers.
Pro Ball NW (Mariners): Bradley vs. Saunders
Would the Mariners actually consider giving LF back to Milton Bradley? Masochists.
Weaver's Tantrum (Orioles): Roberts' Neck
The O's shots at respectability will take a tumble if Brian Roberts' neck doesn't heal.
Baseball Time in Arlington (Rangers): The Crucible
How hard is it to be above replacement level? Prashanth Francis does some cool math, makes some charts, and comes up with the answer.
The Ray Area: Did I invent a time machine?
Mark understandably goes off on Ken Rosenthal's suggestion that baseball may revisit contraction, and that the Rays could be on the chopping block.
Fire Brand of the American League (Red Sox): Red Sox Shut Down Doubront
The Red Sox are taking the conservative route with their young starter.
Royals Authority: Rewind Yourself
Craig Brown breaks down the seriously deranged diatribe that Jason Kendall laid down this week.
The Daily Fungo: Tigers Podcast 128
In which Mike touches on the Miguel Cabreara situation and the 2B competition.
Nick's Twins Blog: Span's Grounders Must Get Moving
How can Denard Span turn it around after a disappointing 2010?
It's About the Money, Stupid (Yankees): It's Not Personal Sonny, It's Strictly Business
Brien takes Mitch Williams to task for his idiotic and immature take on the Rangers/Michael Young situation.
Labels:
baseball,
SweetSpot Roundup
Predicting the Hall of Fame Votes, Part 5: 2032-2036
By Bill
And so here we are, at the end of our epic, week-long, five-part series in which we try to guess at the BBWAA voting results for the next 25 years. And this is the part in which you really see exactly how hard this is, because things completely stop making sense. But it sure is fun!
For the rules, such as they are, check out Part 1 here. And here is part 2, part 3, and part 4. And here's our series wrap-up. And away we go!
And so here we are, at the end of our epic, week-long, five-part series in which we try to guess at the BBWAA voting results for the next 25 years. And this is the part in which you really see exactly how hard this is, because things completely stop making sense. But it sure is fun!
For the rules, such as they are, check out Part 1 here. And here is part 2, part 3, and part 4. And here's our series wrap-up. And away we go!
Labels:
baseball,
hall of fame,
HOF projection series
Thursday, February 24, 2011
Predicting the Hall of Fame Votes, Part 4: 2027-2031
By The Common Man
As you probably are aware from the title, this is part 4 of our attempt to project the BBWAA Hall of Fame voting out for the next 25 years. This installment covers 2027-2031. Parts 1, 2, and 3 are here, here and here. Part 5 is here, and here's our wrap-up.
Just so Bill knows, The Common Man plans to over throw his space-regime in 2027, with the help of a robot butler named Ken Phelps Jr., the sage advice of the still-living head of Joe Torre, the strength and daring of unfrozen Evan Longoria and the gumption and inspiration instilled by the ghost of Marvin Miller. We will install a space-theocracy, based around the divinity of the Great Mauer, and make all unbelievers shag fly balls. Praise be the Mauer. The Mack and Stieb Leagues will continue uninterrupted, except that half the DHs will be shot.
We continue to cleave very closely to each other in the players, if not the years of selection here:
As you probably are aware from the title, this is part 4 of our attempt to project the BBWAA Hall of Fame voting out for the next 25 years. This installment covers 2027-2031. Parts 1, 2, and 3 are here, here and here. Part 5 is here, and here's our wrap-up.
Just so Bill knows, The Common Man plans to over throw his space-regime in 2027, with the help of a robot butler named Ken Phelps Jr., the sage advice of the still-living head of Joe Torre, the strength and daring of unfrozen Evan Longoria and the gumption and inspiration instilled by the ghost of Marvin Miller. We will install a space-theocracy, based around the divinity of the Great Mauer, and make all unbelievers shag fly balls. Praise be the Mauer. The Mack and Stieb Leagues will continue uninterrupted, except that half the DHs will be shot.
We continue to cleave very closely to each other in the players, if not the years of selection here:
Labels:
baseball,
hall of fame,
HOF projection series
Wednesday, February 23, 2011
Adam Wainwright and the Cardinals' Playoff Hopes
By The Common Man
Today’s shocking news out of Cardinals camp, broken by Derrick Goold of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, that ace Adam Wainwright likely has a “significant injury” and is possibly facing Tommy John surgery, is a huge blow to the Cardinals playoff chances for several reasons.
One reason is that the Cardinals were not that far out in front of their competition. Both Dan Szymborski’s ZiPS system and Baseball Prospectus were high on the Cards, predicting them to win the NL Central by a handful of games each. So any major injury to one of the big four (Carpenter, Wainwright, Pujols, and Holliday) was sure to put the Cardinals behind the 8-ball. And no one in the NL Central is likely to challenge for the Wild Card. So there’s little doubt the Cardinals playoff odds just took a big hit.
Today’s shocking news out of Cardinals camp, broken by Derrick Goold of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, that ace Adam Wainwright likely has a “significant injury” and is possibly facing Tommy John surgery, is a huge blow to the Cardinals playoff chances for several reasons.
One reason is that the Cardinals were not that far out in front of their competition. Both Dan Szymborski’s ZiPS system and Baseball Prospectus were high on the Cards, predicting them to win the NL Central by a handful of games each. So any major injury to one of the big four (Carpenter, Wainwright, Pujols, and Holliday) was sure to put the Cardinals behind the 8-ball. And no one in the NL Central is likely to challenge for the Wild Card. So there’s little doubt the Cardinals playoff odds just took a big hit.
Labels:
Adam Wainwright,
Albert Pujols,
baseball,
St. Louis Cardinals
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)