Monday, October 10, 2011

Who Am I?

By Mark Smith
Stereotypes are interesting social phenomena. While they are almost always given a negative connotation, stereotypes are actually quite useful descriptions. Let’s take a look at an example. If I wanted to describe to you an overweight white person with a Southern accent, a John Deere hat, jeans, and a wife beater t-shirt, it is a lot easier to say “hillbilly” than all of that (sorry to anyone currently wearing such a thing; this is only example, and I’m about to justify my use of it). It saves a lot of time to be able to simply use our social observations to make a quick description of a person. The problem, however, is in the use of stereotypes. Instead of using them simply as descriptors, we attach judgments to those images or assume they are a certain way (often negative), and we often do so without knowing much about the person. The stereotype, therefore, isn’t the problem. It’s the prejudice we use to associate with those images.

In baseball, we also have certain stereotypes, but we like to use the phrase “profiles for the position”. We have a certain image of what a catcher is supposed to be, of what a left fielder should be, and what a second baseman should be. When players don’t fit those profiles, it often becomes difficult to accept their contributions. Take Carl Crawford (well, pre-2011 anyway) and Brett Gardner, for example. They don’t fit the usual “mold” of a left fielder, and because they get a lot of their value from defense and baserunning, it was hard for people to accept that they were better than the traditional big bopper. On the flip side, shortstops such as Omar Vizquel are supposed to play good defense and run the bases, so he gets plenty of credit for having done so.

Now, these “profiles” can be helpful. They are there for a reason, and it is generally helpful to find guys who fit the “mold”. The thing to remember, however, is that there is value in people who don’t fit the traditional mold, and we shouldn’t judge someone based on how well he/ fits that mold. Looking at the person and observing what they bring to the table is always advised before making any judgments.

And after all that, here are players at each position who have had the most stereotypical (not the best) years for a player at the position. I’ll give a vague description of the player. You need to either remember or write down your guesses, and at the very end of the post, I’ll put the answers (well, at least my answers; feel free to argue). Here we go:

Friday, October 7, 2011

How Much Is a GM Worth?


I still can’t believe the Marlins gave up real, live human beings for Ozzie Guillen. Nothing about that situation makes any sense whatsoever. The Marlins have repeatedly shown they have no idea how to handle public relations or get their employees to handle public relations in an appropriate manner, and Ozzie is the Pandora’s box of public relations nightmares. Owner Jeffrey Loria is a nutcase who can’t sit still for more than four months, and Ozzie’s actions will make him stir like he’s got ants in his pants. Even looking at this from a pure baseball perspective, Ozzie is about as good of a tactician as I am a tennis player (though I always swing for the fences). Then, the Marlins gave up two decent arms that could be late-inning relievers, and even if that isn’t much, 1-2 wins a season is way more than the wins Ozzie will cost the team. About the only thing Ozzie has going for him is that he’s Hispanic, but I’m not really sure if that matters that much or not to the 1,430 Marlins fans. The trade was just ridiculous all the way around, and if this is what they meant by Loria having more say in baseball operations, I no longer worry about the Marlins as Morrison and whoever else ticks him off will be traded for a stereo system and a scoreboard upgrade shortly.

Anyway, what this made me wonder about was the value of a GM. Managers could be worth a few wins if they didn’t all make the same decisions, but GMs make quite different decisions all the time. They have to. They can’t make the same decisions, don’t live under the same circumstances, and have differing ideas on what builds a good team. Through all of this, they have the most impact on the team. They build it from the ground up, and they could have a huge impact on the number of wins a team has. So when it comes to the Cubs possibly trading something to get Theo Epstein from Boston, I have no idea what to think, but here are a few thoughts.

1) If Ozzie brought back two decent prospects, the Red Sox have to demand a premium prospect at least.

2) Is there even a way to try to quantify a GM’s value? Valuing managers appears difficult enough, but they have definite cause-effect relationships between decisions on the field. When they bunt, we know the difference in run expectancy. How do you evaluate Cashman losing out on Cliff Lee and going to Freddy Garcia and Bartolo Colon?

Friday Forum: Our Award Picks

Another Friday, another forum. This week, I (Bill again) polled the TPA staff and got full ballots from each of us for each of the "major" awards: AL & NL MVP, Cy Young, Rookie of the Year, and Manager of the Year. 


The Platoon Advantage is a proud member of the Baseball Bloggers Alliance, and this post doubles as our site's ballot for their parallel awards: the Stan Musial Award (for the top player in each league), the Walter Johnson Award (for the top pitcher), the Willie Mays Award (top rookie) and the Connie Mack Award (top manager). Accordingly, the "ballots" below represent an aggregate ballot formed from combining all our picks; each first place vote got a number of points equal to the number of slots on the ballot (10 for MVP, 5 for Cy Young, 3 for the others), and each one-step-lower vote got one point less, such that the last slot on the ballot was good for one point. For a spreadsheet showing each of our individual ballots, click here. 


We've got a tie for the AL MVP, which is fine, but then I flipped a coin to determine the AL Stan Musial Award winner. I also flipped a coin to determine the last spot on our AL Connie Mack Award ballot. Our comments were submitted in different ways; sorry for the inconsistencies. If it helps, it kind of bugs me too.

Wednesday, October 5, 2011

Baseball Improvement


By Mark Smith

I won’t try to deny it. I love Home Improvement. Though I could attempt to tell you that I am ashamed to admit that I liked the show, I will still sit there and watch episodes of the show if I could find them. It was corny, cheesy, and wasn’t much more than the average sit-com, but I identified with the show more than others. Perhaps it was because the family mirrored my own. My father isn’t exactly Tim Allen, but my family had 2 parents and 3 sons, the youngest of them named Mark (me!). Perhaps it was because I grew up as the kids grew up, and every time I watched an episode again, I could find a new point as I began to see things from the perspective of the kid that happened to be my age, making the show unintentionally (or maybe intentionally, now that I think about it) versatile and long-lasting.

Of course, none of the actors have really gone on to do anything. Tim Allen did some really crappy movies and looks to be the head of a crappy sit-com. I’ve seen Patricia Richardson in a few things but not much. Jonathan Taylor Thomas pretty much fell off the planet once his teenage cuteness wore off. And Richard Karn was or is still (?) the host of Family Feud, which is like asking for career euthanasia. Nevertheless, the show was quite successful with several good supporting actors surrounding a somewhat star in his peak.

But Tim Allen’s new show got to me thinking about the show and how much I miss it, and like most things that I think about, I started relating it back to baseball and re-casted the show. What follows is the absurd result.

Monday, October 3, 2011

Joe West's Crew, Part 4: Final 2011 Ejection Data

By The Common Man

Joe Mother-effing West
It recently has come to our attention that Joe West… Joe Mother-effing West…is umpiring in the postseason, along with his former partner in crime Angel Hernandez (the two were separated mid-season by Major League Baseball, who was clearly taking the elementary school approach of having two troublemakers sit on opposite sides of the classroom). This realization blew The Common Man’s mind given that just last year West was ranked by players as the 2nd worst umpire in the Majors, and he’s had no shortage of controversial run-ins with players and managers since then. Indeed, as The Common Man pointed out at midseason, Joe West has promoted a culture of confrontation and quick thumbs that was interfering with the integrity of the games in which he was umpiring, changing their course and making West and his crew the central focus.


At mid-season, The Common Man reported that Joe was tied for second (with crew-mate Angel Campos) for most ejections in the Majors, and his crew was lapping the field in terms of the number of players, coaches, fans, and mascots they ejected. Since the regular season is done, and West and Hernandez could play a large role in October’s action, here are the updated and final ejection standings for 2011:

A more sophisticted PLAYOFFS+ metric

by Jason Wojciechowski

As I'm sure you recall, I've proposed that different people have different theories of value. Some of us (myself included) would prefer to strip as much team context as we can out of a player's performance when arguing for individual awards like the MVP and Cy Young. (I called this theory of value WINS+.) Others, though, think that the entire point of the regular season is to help your team get to the playoffs. You see this in arguments that only players on contending teams should be eligible for the MVP.

This, I argued in that post, is an entirely rational position. (I called this theory of value PLAYOFFS+.) The problem is that it's usually applied in an ad hoc fashion, providing excuses for a voter to ignore a better performance because that voter thinks, for whatever unarticulated reason, that the lesser player provided more value by pushing his team near or into the playoffs. I've previously put together a naive but consistent way to implement PLAYOFFS+ -- only players whose teams make the playoffs by a margin slimmer than that individual's WAR total are eligible, and the player, of that group, with the most WAR wins. That approach was rife with problems, some of which I've attempted to address here.

Saturday, October 1, 2011

Poetry Saturday: "Blue-Butterfly Day"

by Jason Wojciechowski

Welcome to Poetry Saturday. The blogfathers have, for some reason, given me editing privileges here on The Platoon Advantage. I have managed to restrain myself for a time, but here, I take advantage.

Courtesy of the eMule.com Poetry Archives's "Random Poem" button:

Blue-Butterfly Day
by Robert Frost

It is blue-butterfly day here in spring,
And with these sky-flakes down in flurry on flurry
There is more unmixed color on the wing
Than flowers will show for days unless they hurry.

But these are flowers that fly and all but sing:
And now from having ridden out desire
They lie closed over in the wind and cling
Where wheels have freshly sliced the April mire.

You might think that eMule chose this in a fit of irony -- this is fall, not spring. The days are growing shorter and colder. We're arguing over playoff rosters, not who the last man on the 40-man should be and whether that Rule 5 pick should sit out in the bullpen.

But the Rangers and Rays are on TV as I write this, and while the stands in Arlington aren't unmixed -- there appears to be red, white, and blue in approximately equal proportions -- for sheer quantity, surely no flower (or regular-season baseball game) could compete. The more melancholy second stanza reflects the eventual fate of all but the luckiest of fans -- they will fly and sing and display their colors as long as they can, but eventually they'll go home unhappy as their teams are eliminated.